Why the simplest check in bookkeeping is the one that gets skipped the most
Introduction
Payday Super started on 1 July. The first full quarter has now closed, Q1 BAS is due at the end of this month, and we have all had a proper run at it rather than a nervous first fortnight.
The questions have changed in that time. Back in July it was “what do I actually have to do now?” By August it was “why is my cash flow so tight?” This month it is the one I least like hearing:
“Why does the ATO think I still owe super from July?”
If that is you, or if you have not checked, this is the post to read before you lodge.
The July allocation trap, three months on
This is the big one, and it catches out businesses that did everything right.
Think back to 30 June. You still had a super guarantee obligation outstanding for the June quarter, which was perfectly normal because under the old rules it was not due until 28 July. Then on 1 July, Payday Super began, and you started paying super with every pay run exactly as required.
Here is what the law does with those payments. From 1 July 2026, employer contributions are automatically allocated to the pay period with the oldest outstanding SG liability. You do not get to direct where the money goes.
So for a lot of employers, the super paid in early July for July pay runs was applied against the leftover June quarter obligation instead. The June quarter cleared. The July paydays quietly did not.
The result is a business that has paid super faithfully, on time, every single payday, and still carries a shortfall against those July pay periods.
Why this matters more now than it did in August. A shortfall does not sit still. Interest runs from the payday itself and compounds daily. A gap that opened in July has now been growing for roughly three months. It is still entirely fixable, and it is cheaper to fix today than it will be in January.
If you had any June quarter super outstanding on 1 July, go and look at where your July payments were actually applied. Check your fund confirmations against your payroll records, period by period. Do not assume. This is the single most common thing we are finding.
“Received by” still trips people up
Your contribution is on time when it is received by your employee’s fund, with all the information needed to allocate it to their member account, within seven business days of paying them.
Two words in that sentence cause most of the trouble.
Received. Not sent. Not submitted to your clearing house. Received by the fund. Everything sitting between you and the fund happens inside your seven days, not after them: clearing house processing, banking days, fund processing time, all of it.
Information. A contribution that arrives without the data to match it to the right member account has not really arrived. A wrong member number, a mismatched name, an old fund, a stale USI, and the payment is rejected or suspended. It may bounce back days later, by which point your seven days are mostly gone.
For a new employee the first contribution has a longer window of 20 business days, which is a sensible allowance for sorting out their details and stapled fund. Every payday after that is back to seven.
The practical version: submit on payday, not on day six.
What a full quarter has actually surfaced
Four patterns, in the order we see them most.
Cash flow, by a distance. Super has moved from a quarterly obligation to a payday one. Money that used to sit in your account for weeks now leaves with the wages. Nothing has changed about how much super you owe, only when it goes, and that is enough to make a business that was comfortable feel genuinely tight. If things have felt harder since winter and you have not been able to name why, this is almost always it.
Rejected contributions from stale employee data. Details that were slightly wrong were survivable under a quarterly system because you had time to sort them out. On a seven day clock they are not. Old fund details and mismatched member numbers are generating far more rejections than they used to.
Clearing house timing. Businesses used to submitting and considering the job done are finding that processing time eats into a deadline with very little room in it.
Assuming the software has it handled. Payroll software will generally prompt you, but a prompt is not a payment and a submission is not a receipt. Someone still has to confirm the money reached the fund.
The ATO’s position for this first year
Some genuinely good news, and it has not changed.
The ATO has published its compliance approach for the first year of Payday Super, and it is a facilitative one. An employer who is genuinely paying super on payday, but who has the occasional late contribution because details were wrong or a fund rejected a payment, and who fixes it promptly, is treated as low risk and is not the focus of compliance action in year one.
That is a sensible, human position and it should take real pressure off.
But read what it actually says. It covers honest mistakes, promptly corrected, by employers who are genuinely trying to comply. It is not a grace period and it is not a waiver. An employer who has simply carried on paying quarterly is not covered by it. And “promptly corrected” is doing a lot of work in that sentence, which is another reason not to let a July shortfall run into a fourth month.
One note on the tax treatment of the super guarantee charge and any penalties attached to it: that is a tax question rather than a BAS one, and it belongs with your accountant. Please do have that conversation rather than assuming the old rules still apply.
Your checklist before the BAS deadline
Q1 BAS for the July to September quarter is due 28 October, or 25 November if you lodge through a registered BAS agent. Either way, this is the natural moment to reconcile the quarter properly.
- Check your July allocations. If you had June quarter super outstanding on 1 July, confirm where those July payments actually landed.
- Confirm receipt, not submission. For every pay run since 1 July, check the contribution reached the fund inside seven business days.
- Reconcile super for the whole quarter against your payroll reports, not just the most recent run.
- Clean up employee super details. Fund name, USI, member number, name spelling. Fix the near misses before they become rejections.
- Check your STP submissions all went through. Failed lodgements accumulate quietly and become a painful afternoon later.
- Find out your clearing house processing time and work backwards from it.
- Deal with any shortfall now. It gets more expensive every day it sits there, and prompt correction is exactly what the ATO’s first year approach rewards.
- Check who is handling your payroll and super. Payroll and superannuation guarantee work are BAS services. If the person doing them for a fee is not a registered BAS agent, or is not working under the supervision of one, they cannot legally provide those services.
One eye on December
Worth thinking about now rather than in six weeks.
The December quarter is the hardest of the year to stay on top of, and Payday Super has made it harder. If you are closing over Christmas, annual leave gets paid out, often in a lump and sometimes with leave loading on top, and the super on those wages now goes out on payday rather than at the end of the quarter. Public holiday loadings can make December and January pay runs noticeably larger than usual.
So map your December and January pay runs now: the actual dates, the actual amounts, and the super that travels with each one. If you are planning a shutdown, the leave conversation with your team needs to happen well before December, because written notice requirements apply.
If you are looking for help with this
Payroll and super are BAS services, so the person doing them for you for a fee needs to be a registered BAS agent, or working under the supervision of one and telling you so.
You can check anyone on the TPB public register in about thirty seconds, by name, business name or registration number. It is worth doing for whoever currently handles your payroll, whether that is me or somebody else.
It is also worth asking what professional body they belong to. The two main ones for bookkeepers in Australia are the Institute of Certified Bookkeepers and the Australian Bookkeepers Network. Membership is not a legal requirement, but with a change of this size still bedding in, someone plugged into a technical advice line and ongoing professional development is a reasonable thing to want.
The honest summary
Payday Super is not a difficult system once it is running properly. It is more work at the start, less across the year, and better for employees, who now watch their super arrive with their wages rather than three months later.
But the first quarter of any new system is where the problems live, and the July allocation issue in particular is one you will not spot unless you go looking for it.
If you have not checked, check. October is a much better month to find a shortfall than February.
Useful links
- ATO, about Payday Super: https://www.ato.gov.au/businesses-and-organisations/super-for-employers/payday-super/about-payday-super
- ATO, payment deadlines for Payday Super: https://www.ato.gov.au/businesses-and-organisations/super-for-employers/paying-super-on-payday/payment-deadlines-for-payday-super
- ATO, compliance in the first year of Payday Super: https://www.ato.gov.au/businesses-and-organisations/super-for-employers/missed-or-late-payday-super-payments/getting-it-right-compliance-in-the-first-year-of-payday-super
- ATO, Single Touch Payroll: https://www.ato.gov.au/businesses-and-organisations/hiring-and-paying-your-workers/single-touch-payroll
- ATO, BAS due dates: https://www.ato.gov.au/businesses-and-organisations/preparing-lodging-and-paying/business-activity-statements-bas/due-dates-for-lodging-and-paying-your-bas
- Fair Work Ombudsman, Payday Super: https://www.fairwork.gov.au/newsroom/news/payday-super-new-rules-starting-1-july-2026
- Fair Work, directing leave during a shutdown: https://www.fairwork.gov.au/leave/annual-leave/directing-an-employee-to-take-annual-leave/direction-to-take-annual-leave-during-a-shut-down
- Fair Work, end of year rules and entitlements: https://www.fairwork.gov.au/newsroom/news/rules-and-entitlements-during-the-end-of-year-holiday-season
- TPB public register, to check any practitioner: https://www.tpb.gov.au/public-register
- Institute of Certified Bookkeepers: https://www.icb.org.au/
- Australian Bookkeepers Network: https://austbook.net/
- Our payroll services: https://www.kmlbookkeeping.com.au/services/payroll/
If you would like someone to go through your pay runs since July and confirm your super landed where it should have, that is the job we are doing most at the moment. It is usually a short piece of work and the relief when it comes back clean is worth it on its own.
Call me on 0402 831 073 or email kay@kmlbookkeeping.com.au
Kay Laws
Registered BAS Agent, KML Bookkeeping

